Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Home for all your discussion of basketball statistical analysis.
Nathan
Posts: 137
Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 4:30 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Nathan »

Crow wrote:Ok, thanks for spelling your view out.

But, if you are game, let's go further.

Doncic projected above Simmons. What about Giannis?

Is Giannis a Harden-Love hybrid? How much chance do you give Doncic to get to Giannis' current level? Do you give him any chance of surpassing Giannis?
Giannis's current level varies a lot depending on who you ask. It's a doubly hard comparison because, like Simmons, Giannis is likely to become one of the NBA's best defensive players if he's not already.

From a purely offensive perspective, though, I think Doncic's upside is nearly limitless. His passing volume and efficiency are excellent. His free throw volume and efficiency are excellent. And his 3-point shooting volume and efficiency perhaps just shy of excellent. That could be considered the holy trinity of offensive skills...has an 18 year old ever been so strong in all three areas? I don't think so.
Crow
Posts: 10565
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2011 11:10 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Crow »

When I said ok to good before the ok meant league average. Some would call that good or even very good. I may shift to calling it good. By good I before meant clearly better than that. I probably should call that very good to lessen terminology discrepancies in evaluation discussions.

By my previous terminology Simmons is average on ws/48, good on BPM and RPM. He could be upgraded with the new standards. And so would Doncic in my off the cuff remark.
Crow
Posts: 10565
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2011 11:10 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Crow »

How does Doncic at 18's stats & skills compare to Giannis, LBJ, Durant, Curry, Harden, Love, P Hardaway, Magic Johnson, Jordan, McGrady, Kobe, Bird, Iverson... who else? That would make for an interesting chart. If he is already determined or at least assessed as best Euro, let's move the chains...
Nathan
Posts: 137
Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 4:30 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Nathan »

Crow wrote:Any prediction about "leadership quality" of Doncic and for those other names? By what means if any can we project leadership quality? Individual stats alone usually don't get the ultimate prize.

RPM / BPM ratio? Or just high on both? Actual win% vs Pythagorean expected? Clutch and crunch play? Peak performances? Leadership assessment of interview texts? Visual analysis of teammate interactions? Statistical responses to adverse conditions including road games, losing streaks, top opponents (individual & team) but more granular too (poor shooting streaks, not getting to line experiences, pair data with stars, avg. and weak players, etc.)

Collaboration skills with coaches & GMs? Assessment of importance of various goals? Assessment of confidence level or confidence type? Listening skills / coachability? Ability to rise above coaching? Teammate reaction to star behavior & personality on and off court? In what ways is he like / not like Hakeem, Manu, Pau, Dirk as a person / player? (and Hezonja, Bogdanovic, Porzingis, Giannis, Galinari, Jokic, Mirotic, JVal and other non NBA titlists, yet)
I'll try to answer point by point as best as I can:

-Seems to show good leadership. Vocal, wears his heart on his sleeve. Being the youngest guy on the team he isn't a lockerroom leader beyond a certain point, but on the court the ball is almost always in his hands in crunch time.

-I'd guess he's modestly better by box score stats than by plus/minus stats; he's arguably the best player in Europe by box score, and quick analysis suggests he's at least a mild positive in plus/minus terms (that's above RM's baseline, which is something like +10 per 100).

-Qualitatively it seems like he's struggled some in crunch time, but he wants the ball in his hands (though he may look to pass rather than shoot). On the flip side he's had some of his best games against the league's best teams, most notably 20 points, 8 boards, 10 assists, and 2 steals in a road win against #2 Fenerbahce a few weeks ago, and 11 points, 12 boards, 8 assists in the Eurobasket semis in a win over championship favorite Spain. He had a solid clutch performance a few days ago too, scoring on a pair of free throws and a floater, then assisting on the game winner.

-RM has overperformed relative to pythagorean in ACB play, underperformed in Euroleague, so a wash overall there.

-With RM having lost 4 of their last 5 in Euroleague play and trailing by 9 going into the 4th on the road against a solid Olympiacos team, Doncic scored or assisted on 20 points in the fourth quarter and overtime in a comeback bid that ultimately fell short. Ended up scoring 33 points in 38 minutes. He definitely plays to win no matter what, though perhaps he is sometimes prone to slipping into a more passive role, especially when playing with another point guard.

-Will get on the floor or dive into the stands for loose balls, almost no matter the game situation. Can be aggressive to a fault on defense, closing out too hard and giving up a blow-by. As I mentioned before, if there's a couple seconds left in a quarter/half, he'll actively call for the ball to try to get a shot up from 3/4 court.

-Coach's son. Seems coachable, and haven't heard anything to the contrary. Accepts coming off the bench in spite of being pretty clearly the best player on the team.

-Very daring passer, regularly attempts high degree of difficulty passes (between the legs passes, no-look passes) with mixed results. Fast with the ball in the open court, wants to turn every play into a fast break and expects his teammates to run with him. Once he has a head of steam he keeps going, even if it's 1-on-4 (again with mixed results). His confidence is more tempered as a shooter; as soon as he draws the double team he's immediately looking to pass, and usually does well in these scenarios. Doesn't normally chuck 3's early in the shot clock, even if he has a little room. He's not lightning quick getting his shot up off the dribble, which plays into this.

-Manu is a bit of a lazy comparison for him in general, but I think his personality is similar. He's not a freak athlete like Manu is, but he's bigger and stronger. Same "master of chaos" style of play.

This is a good article if you want to read about him at length. http://www.espn.com/nba/story/_/id/2066 ... uka-doncic

Some excerpts:

Eager to spend as much time on the court as possible, Doncic would beg his parents to go practice with the older teams on his off days. "I often told Luka, 'Tomorrow you are free -- be at home, play with your toys or something, you have to rest,'" said Jernej Smolnikar, Doncic's selection team coach from 2007 to 2011. "The next day at 12 his parents would call me saying, 'Please can Luka come to practice, he's begging to play.' His passion to compete was unbelievable."



Doncic was more physically gifted and skilled than all of his peers, and many of his elders, but it was his mental makeup, competitive nature and incredible basketball instincts that impressed most at that age. Whether it was an innate characteristic or a product of growing up around the game, the Slovenian sensation was wired differently -- joyous and full of life, yet confident with a killer mentality.



CSKA Moscow mainstay and former Euroleague defensive player of the year Kyle Hines remembers first seeing a 16-year-old Doncic on the personnel report as the Russian powerhouse prepared for a game against Real Madrid in January 2016.

"I looked at my scouting report and thought to myself, this kid is 16 years old?" Hines said.

With Llull, Real Madrid's star guard, out due to injury, Doncic was likely to play extended minutes. The CSKA coaching staff wanted to test the teenage Doncic defensively while forcing him to beat them from the perimeter on the other end. Expecting the young Slovenian guard to struggle with the magnitude of playing in a road Euroleague game, CSKA went under every ball screen, defending Doncic "Ricky Rubio style," as Hines explained.

Doncic made 3 triples in a two-minute, second-quarter stretch, finishing with 12 points and five rebounds in 13 minutes, proving to Hines and CSKA that his thirst for pressure existed even in the Euroleague.



"For him it's natural," said Igor Kokoskov, Slovenian national team head coach and longtime NBA assistant. "He's fearless. He loves to compete. He loves to be on the biggest stage."

"I feel like I want to be the hero of the game, you know?" Doncic said. "Every time I wanted the ball in my hands, from the very beginning. I have missed some important shots before but you need to learn from this. You need to move on. If you have a nice game or a bad game, you will have a thousand more games."
Crow
Posts: 10565
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2011 11:10 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Crow »

I saw that article and re-read it now. It is a fine article. But I like what we did here too. I like having both. I tweeted about this thread. Not sure how much it means to others. But we each added stuff.
Crow
Posts: 10565
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2011 11:10 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Crow »

A question I have is did Mike S. not hear a single doubt or negative word about Doncic or did he decide to not include it? I think there is probably something to doubt or consider potentially negative about any young player (or people in general). If any future writers are open to considering pluses and minuses, I'd say do it and look what was said here and @bballatrategy twitter. Even though I might practice one hand writing (usually to balance or out of time rush) I prefer one hand / another hand writing / reading from one person or cumulatively from several. But if u want a clean, simple story; well then, u probably won't. Maybe it comes out in the mix eventually for those who want it / look for it. If I read a scouting report and it was 100% positive, I'd ask questions and follow-up. Maybe it is right but I'd need to double check it.
josecarlos
Posts: 98
Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2017 10:11 pm
Location: Spain
Contact:

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by josecarlos »

Nathan wrote:
Crow wrote:Yeah. It is not a thin case like Ntilikina.

I don't know how high to project Doncic. What little I studied (compared to time needed to make a pro decision) just seems enough to say that maybe the ultra-praise might be too free and is maybe not treating the context change with enough caution. Rubio was young and supposed to get a lot better and fix his flaws but he ended up far less than projected.
That's a fair point, though I'd argue it's more a lesson in the fact that all great 18-year-olds don't go on to become great players in their primes, rather than a lesson in European stats failing to translate to the NBA. For whatever reason, Rubio went from scoring ~17 points per 40 on ~55% true shooting at age 17 to under 10 points per 40 on under 50% true shooting at age 20, before coming to the NBA at age 21. Bizarre.
Rubio from 18 to 20 was playing in F.C. Barcelona with a horrible coach for young people, Xavi Pascual.
Nathan
Posts: 137
Joined: Sat Jun 22, 2013 4:30 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Nathan »

Crow wrote:A question I have is did Mike S. not hear a single doubt or negative word about Doncic or did he decide to not include it? I think there is probably something to doubt or consider potentially negative about any young player (or people in general). If any future writers are open to considering pluses and minuses, I'd say do it and look what was said here and @bballatrategy twitter. Even though I might practice one hand writing (usually to balance or out of time rush) I prefer one hand / another hand writing / reading from one person or cumulatively from several. But if u want a clean, simple story; well then, u probably won't. Maybe it comes out in the mix eventually for those who want it / look for it. If I read a scouting report and it was 100% positive, I'd ask questions and follow-up. Maybe it is right but I'd need to double check it.
One thing I've seen him do that makes me at least mildly concerned is he sometimes claps his hands at teammates to ask for the ball, e.g. when they're trotting up the court in transition and he wants to push the pace. NBA vets probably won't appreciate that sort of thing. I can imagine him clashing with teammates who he thinks are taking plays off. This sounds like I'm half singing his praises while pretending to criticize him, but really, with a much more condensed schedule and longer games he'll have to learn to take it easier some of the time. His conditioning is no doubt better than Trae Young's, but it'll be a task for both of those guys to pace themselves through 48 minute games and 82 game seasons.

Another thing is that his emotions sometimes boil over or get in the way of his game. Here, he's literally on the verge of tears as he's benched due to his poor play in a playoff game:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=krKTwN-kde0

Here, he loses his temper after a controversial flagrant+technical foul call leads to his ejection:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WPj0jyOsxqk
josecarlos wrote:Rubio from 18 to 20 was playing in F.C. Barcelona with a horrible coach for young people, Xavi Pascual.
Good to know!
Crow
Posts: 10565
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2011 11:10 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Crow »

Yeah I think he and team will need to monitor his NBA teammate relations and try to avoid them going distant or negative.

Doncic shooting 42% overall raw fg% from field in last 10 games. 26% from 3 pt land. His "PIR" has been below his season average in 6 of last 7 Euroleague games. Recent ACB performances have been up and down but about season average. No games over 20 points so far this month in 7 games.
Dr Positivity
Posts: 331
Joined: Thu Sep 20, 2012 6:44 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Dr Positivity »

This is a tough call because I'm more confident in predicting productive European big men than I am anything else in the draft, but I'm not sure if that extends to perimeter players or not, the comparison points aren't there, the best I can say is that low productive European perimeter prospects usually suck so maybe that means the great ones will be great. Still you have to think these numbers mean he has some % upside to be one of the best players of all time, and probably has the highest floor too
Crow
Posts: 10565
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2011 11:10 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Crow »

# games in last 9 ACB and 9 Euroleague games Doncic shot better than 33% from the 22 foot 3point line? 4. Or 22% of these recent games.
josecarlos
Posts: 98
Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2017 10:11 pm
Location: Spain
Contact:

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by josecarlos »

Yesterday was played the final of a very important trophy in Spain called "Copa del Rey". This trophy is played between the best 8 teams of the ACB league (Spanish league) and her format is equal than March Madness, if you win you still goin on, if you lose you go to home. The final was played between R.Madrid C.F. and F.C.Barcelona with the result of 90 - 92 for F.C.Barcelona.

Doncic played 25 minuts and made 14 points with these stats: 2/8 FG, 0/4 3P, 12/16 FT. Stats: http://www.acb.com/fichas/CREY82007.php

I'm pretty sure that in the NBA Doncic will not be so protected by the referees like in Europe. I say Europe because in Euroliga the referees protect him too much too.
Last edited by josecarlos on Mon Feb 19, 2018 8:54 am, edited 1 time in total.
josecarlos
Posts: 98
Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2017 10:11 pm
Location: Spain
Contact:

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by josecarlos »

Crow wrote:Yeah I think he and team will need to monitor his NBA teammate relations and try to avoid them going distant or negative.

Doncic shooting 42% overall raw fg% from field in last 10 games. 26% from 3 pt land. His "PIR" has been below his season average in 6 of last 7 Euroleague games. Recent ACB performances have been up and down but about season average. No games over 20 points so far this month in 7 games.
In the last games, Doncic seems to be tired and exhausted. He usually started the games and lately he start from the bench. I don't know how he is going to evolution this season.
josecarlos
Posts: 98
Joined: Sun Oct 08, 2017 10:11 pm
Location: Spain
Contact:

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by josecarlos »

I have to say one more thing about Doncic. He has a very bad attitude against other players. If he is fouled usually reacts against the other player with very bad manners. Sorry about my english I don't know how it's said this adjective in english, but in spanish we usually say that "El es un niñato" I think that in english is said "He is a brat".

This happend at the end of the final of "Copa del Rey" yesterday.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FQ0YeyhqjlA

Second 20. Pierre Oriola maybe touch him with his shoulder and the rest is history :)

Twitter from Oriola:
Pierre Oriola‏Cuenta verificada @PierreOriola

La acción con @luka7doncic en ningún momento es intencionada ni voy hacerle daño. Corro directo a mis compañeros y topamos sin querer. De verdad que no voy con la intención de hacerle daño ni nada de esto que vais diciendo. No soy ese tipo de jugador.
I try to translate ...

The action with @luka7doncic is not intentional and I don't want to hurt him. I run directly to my mates and we crashing. I haven't any intention to hurt him. I'm not that kind of player.

Sorry if my english is not so good, again :(
Crow
Posts: 10565
Joined: Thu Apr 14, 2011 11:10 pm

Re: Euroleague BPM (and, how good is Luka Doncic?)

Post by Crow »

Thanks for the information. Your Englsh is pretty good.

Small correction: the boxscore says he was 1 for 8 from the field.

Several people have said he looks exhausted. He has played just 13 games in 50 days. Maybe it is from the summer. Maybe he should give up summer national ball for the NBA. He almost certainly won't though.

His 3 pt shot has mostly disappeared in recent weeks and was still gone yesterday.

You said he get favorable referee treatment with fouls against his defenders. Do you think he also gets favorable non-calls of travels & carries? I do but would like other opinions.

Another thing I noticed in his season stats: 4 of his 5 best overall games came in Euroleague. Some people tell me ACB is better than Euroleague. On the other hand Real Madrid is way less dominant in Euroleague than ACB. So league quality is still unclear to me. Maybe there is difference between top and middle to bottom?
Post Reply