Page 10 of 10
Re: Vote players into our alltime top 140, etc.
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 1:39 pm
by MW00
Write in: Kirlienko, Roundfield
Re: Vote players into our alltime top 140, etc.
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 1:44 pm
by Mike G
Alrighty, then.
We've promoted 19 players/careers to the preliminary top 134 : Anthony, Cassell, Chambers, Cheeks, Coleman, Cummings, Penny Hardaway, King, Macauley, Mikkelsen, Andre Miller, Oakley, Price, Rondo, Schrempf, Stoudemire, Strickland, Thorpe, Buck Williams.
Write-in candidates who failed to get more than one vote in the previous 2 rounds and have been replaced: Dumars, Maravich, Gus Johnson, Ramsey
Re: Vote players into our alltime top 160, etc.
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 2:33 pm
by Mike G
MW, I assume those write-ins were supposed to be in the previous round. We crossed posts.
Roundfield was due to appear in this round anyway; AK in the next one or 2 rounds. So the upshot is that they're on the ballot now and for the duration.
Re: Vote players into our alltime top 160, etc.
Posted: Tue Oct 22, 2013 3:21 pm
by Mike G
Sorted by (1) round of voting, (2) votes, and (3) alphabetically (as listed) -- our 'preliminary' top 134 careers/players thus far:
Code: Select all
1-20 21-40 41-60 61-80 81-100 101-120 121-134
Bird Robinson. Pierce Gasol Sikma Howell. Carmelo
Duncan Barkley Schayes. Mutombo Walton. Chet Walker Cassell
Jordan Baylor Cousy Parker. Brand Laimbeer Chambers
Kareem Wade. Iverson Ben Wallace Divac Mark Jackson Coleman
Lebron Havlicek. McGrady Carter Grant Hill Mo Lucas. King
Magic Ewing Parish Durant Kemp Adams Macauley
Russell Gilmore Paul. Issel T Porter Aguirre Mikkelsen
Shaq. Pettit. Lanier KJ Webber. Archibald Oakley
Garnett Barry Ray Allen. Worthy. Beaty Bobby Jones Penny H
Oscar Cowens Dantley Bellamy Bosh Dandridge Price
Wilt. Drexler Gervin Billups DeBusschere Greer Rondo
Erving Dwight Ginobili Heinsohn DJ Gus Williams Schrempf
Olajuwon. Kidd Jerry Lucas Johnston English Ho Grant Strickland
Kobe McHale McAdoo Marion Hornacek Reed Thorpe
Stockton. Payton. Mourning Marques Lovellette Wilkens.
Karl Malone Frazier Nique Nance. McGinnis Amar'e
Nowitzki Hayes Reggie Arizin Moncrief Cheeks
West. Isiah Thurmond Hagan Rasheed Cummings.
Moses Mikan Unseld. Rodman Sam Jones Andre Miller
Pippen Nash Cunningham Sharman T Hardaway. Buck Williams
[A period indicates the last (alphabetical) name among players who are tied in vote-ranking.]
From this "voters' top xxx", we'll re-start in a 2nd iteration. This just gets us to more of a consensus on whom the candidates should be.
Re: Vote players into our alltime top 160, etc.
Posted: Wed Oct 23, 2013 11:55 am
by Mike G
The 2nd iteration has begun:
viewtopic.php?f=2&t=8366
Re: Vote players into our alltime top 160, etc.
Posted: Sat Oct 26, 2013 2:10 pm
by Mike G
This looks likely to be the last round of phase 1 ranking. We have yet to see some very good players.
Next 25 would be Richie Guerin, Paul Silas, Lou Hudson, Earl Monroe, Connie Hawkins, Larry Kenon, Mickey Johnson, Mychal Thompson, Derek Harper, Doc Rivers, Byron Scott, Alvin Robertson, Mitch Richmond, Danny Manning, Hersey Hawkins, Anthony Mason, Steve Smith, Larry Johnson, Shareef Abdul-Raheem, Rashard Lewis, Mike Bibby, Steve Francis, Ron Artest, Kenyon Martin, David West.
After that: Don Nelson, Willie Wise, Calvin Murphy, Pete Maravich, Fred Brown, Randy Smith, Paul Westphal, John Drew, Norm Nixon, Joe Dumars, Xavier McDaniel, AC Green, John Starks, Glen Rice, Christian Laettner, Nick Van Exel, Jamal Mashburn, Glenn Robinson, Arvydas Sabonis, Jerry Stackhouse, Joe Johnson, Gilbert Arenas, Richard Jefferson, Jason Richardson, Andre Iguodala.
A lot of allstars, all-leaguers, and general world-beaters in NBA/ABA history!
We may come back to it during some lull in the conversations.